Should I Accept the First Offer on My House?
Not automatically, and not automatically no either. The first offer deserves a real look, because it often comes from a motivated buyer during the weeks your home gets the most attention. Judge it on the price, the terms, and how likely a better one is to show up, not on the fact that it came first. Your agent can help you put it next to recent sales and current demand.
Why the first offer can be a good one
Realtor.com talked with agents about this in 2025. One said the first 7 to 10 days are typically when a home gets the most online views and showing requests, and that it tends to cool off after that. Another noted that waiting for something better can backfire if the home sits and starts to look stale.
That doesn't mean you should say yes to everything. It means an early offer often reflects real interest at a moment of peak exposure, and you shouldn't dismiss it out of habit.
When it may make sense to wait
- You've just listed and showings are busy. If other agents tell yours that offers are coming, a short wait can create competition. Your agent can set a date and time to review all offers.
- The price was set low on purpose to draw several buyers. In that case, an early offer may not reflect where the market would take it.
- The offer is thin. Low price, long contingencies, or a request for big credits can make it weaker than it looks.
When it may make sense to take it, or counter
- Your home has been on the market for a while and activity has been slow. Turning down a solid offer because it's the first one can be risky if no one else is waiting.
- The terms are clean. A strong price with fewer contingencies, solid financing, and a timeline that fits yours can be worth more than a slightly higher number with more risk.
- You have a deadline, like a job start or a closing on your next home.
- It's close and negotiable. Accepting the first offer doesn't mean accepting every term. One agent in the Realtor.com piece pointed out that early on is when sellers have the most leverage to negotiate timelines, contingencies, and price.
What to compare
- Net proceeds. The price is one line. Subtract concessions, repairs, and closing costs. My post on how much you'll net when you sell in Maryland can help.
- Financing. Is the buyer pre-approved with a lender your agent can vet? Is there a low appraisal risk?
- Contingencies. How long are inspection and financing periods?
- Timing. Does the closing date and possession work for you?
- Evidence. How does the price line up with recent comps and the active competition?
If you want a consistent way to compare, see how to compare offers when selling your house.
What not to do
Don't assume a better buyer is out there just because that's possible. If you don't have signs of other interest, you're betting on someone who hasn't shown up. That bet sometimes pays and sometimes doesn't. Also don't take a first offer only because you're tired of showings. Look at it on its merits.
FAQ
How long do I have to respond to an offer?
Most offers include an expiration date. Responding within a day or two is common practice, but check the offer for its deadline.
Can I counter the first offer?
Yes. You can counter price, credits, timing, or contingencies.
What if the first offer is below asking?
Look at it against comps and decide whether to counter. A lower start isn't a no. It's often the opening of a negotiation.
Should I wait for a weekend of showings?
If your agent sees real interest, a defined review date can help. If not, waiting may only cost time.
Can I accept an offer and still take backup offers?
Often yes, as a backup, but it depends on the contract and your agent's advice.
Next step
Planning to sell in Maryland or DC? See how I price homes and market them, or request a pricing analysis so you know what a good offer looks like before it arrives. Want to talk it through? Grab a free 15-minute call at calendly.com/michaelwaderealtor/15min. No pressure.
Source: Realtor.com, "Should You Take the First Offer on Your Home?" (2025).
Recent Posts











